I promised to write up some of the rocket details for a few people, so here goes…
I’ll start with some pictures of the actual launches, then talk about the technical detail.
Ready for pressurisation
Drogue parachute deployed perfectly, but no main
Probably a good job the main parachute didn't deploy, else we'd have ended up in the trees rather than the brambles. Also learnt that if you stand around pondering for long enough there's bound to be a sillier idiot than you willing to go climbing through the brambles.
Oh, and we did have some minor mishaps too...
Launch video (which I seem unable to embed)
Rocket body pressure chambers
The failed 'Anna Chapman' rocket
After the impressive sight, but inevitable failure of the Anna Chapman last year (launch video) I fancied building something similar but hopefully more successful. Last year we did find that 500ml bottles seemed to have a lot more bang for their buck than 2L bottles but this didn’t deter me too much. I’m still not really sure why it was, but I imagine it had something to do with cross sectional area versus volume. I surmised a longer rocket might well work better.
Inspiration from a rather impressive looking Air Command rocket using asymmetrically spliced bottles.
Air Command Water Rockets is an excellent resource, with some amazing launch videos which I wanted to try and at least go some way towards replicating. After some research I followed their Asymmetric Splice #5 Tutorial to build a number of spliced double-ended bottle sections. I shan’t repeat their tutorial, but I ended up using different glue as PL Premium is all but impossible to get hold of in the UK. I used Sikaflex EBT from Screwfix to seal the splice and a 2:3 Gorilla Glue:Polyfilla mix for the sleeving (more details on this Water Rocket Forum thread with links to Flickr pictures). Needless to say my garage is now covered in Polyfilla and glue; it gets everywhere.
IMPORTANT TIP: Wear gloves when handling Gorilla Glue; and replace said gloves if they break. Even the small amount I got on my thumb through a hole in my glove took over a week to wear off. It’s evil stuff.
The benefit of making a series of pressurisable ‘units’ rather than one long one is that they can be individually static pressure tested and the failures thrown away without affecting the rest. Having said that I am tempted to try and make a three or four bottle long ‘unit’ at some point.
Connected spliced bottles ready for launch
The plan was to then join three or four of these together into a longer rocket using Tornado tubes from Hawkin’s Bazaar; but at £3.50 each they do work out rather expensive and the Northampton branch doesn’t seem to stock them.
Foreground left: Joined bottle connectors with various sized holes to allow air/water through. Foreground right: Gardena nozzles made to fit bottle top. Rear: Failed bottle top connectors.
From a thread on the Water Rocket Forum I came across a bright idea that Dan Brooker from British Water Rockets had to fuse two bottle tops into a coupling. He has made a demonstration video of how to do this. Despite his lack of testing at that stage I thought it worth a go. My success rate was less than one in three and I began to run out of bottle tops, but I found that some of my attempts withstood a static pressure test to 100psi. I’m not sure how much higher they’ll go, but Dan has reported some failures since. YMMV.
Talking of failures… when carrying out static pressure tests be wary of how much water leaks and air is let in – I had an inadvertent launch at 10 o’clock at night into next door but one’s garden.
My old Clarke cable tie based launcher
Martin's Clarke cable tie based launcher, with 21.5mm launch tube
Last year my Clark cable tie design
based launcher sealed only with the assistance of PTFE tape on the outside of the bottles. Martin
had used a carefully sized piece of pipe to get an internal seal, which seemed less hassle and allowed for an internal launch tube. So, I planned to use the internal seal and launch tube for the boosters, more on that in a minute.
New launcher with optional boosters (annotated)
Having read about possible options on Air Command Rockets, I decided to have a go at a Gardena (Hozelock) launch mechanism. Reasons were two-fold: a. it might seal better; b. the smaller nozzle may sustain flight longer (albeit at a lower force, but that comes in handy when using boosters). I could always revert to the old launcher if all else failed.
A safe distance from the launcher - hosepipe and string allows remote compression and launch
Oh, and being the sensible one, I elected to put a length garden hosepipe between the launcher and the pump. This reduced the risk of personal injury in the event of catastrophic failure and also kept the operator somewhat drier.
Others may not have thought ahead so much...
Martin getting a tad soggy. Note: Some of the photos I've used, including this one are from one of the 2010 Ballistics events
Air Command Water Rockets has a nice tutorial and videos about preparing a Gardena nozzle, so I shan’t dwell on that much. As they note, I had trouble finding a nozzle with a seal, so tried using some Sikaflex as a seal with mixed results. Ultimately, it was the nozzle that limited launch pressures to about 80psi, so this is where more work is needed to get a good seal between the Gardena nozzle and the bottle top.
Rather than the direct string pull I sought some mechanical advantage from a level arrangement for the launch release. In use we found that it still needed quite a tug to release and on one occasion the string snapped. Again, this needs more work.
As if I’d not created enough trouble for myself already, I thought it would be cool to have more than one stage. Direct staging mechanisms seemed a little complex for a first go at anything more than the plain bottles we launched last year, so boosters seemed a sensible bet. Again, Air Command Water Rockets provided much of the inspiration with their Drop Away Boosters and Cluster Launcher pages.
The principle behind the boosters was pretty simple, but also very critical with a number of single points of failure (no manned versions of this bottle rocket design). The boosters were set up such that they would produce more force than the main rocket until exhausted at which point they passively drop behind the main stage. That’s the theory at least, my design wasn’t quite as sophisticated or refined as Air Command’s. The pictures below illustrate the coat hanger hook and pen cylinder receptacles making up the mechanism. They didn’t operate particularly smoothly, though maybe a neater effort would have better results – I was pushed for time.
Booster with hooks
Hook receptacles on main body bottle
Overall, the boosters didn’t work out too well. Even with PTFE tape around the booster launch tubes it was difficult to get a good, consistent seal on each of the three bottles; invariably, one let go and began to leak under pressure. And the minor mishap illustrated in the first series of pictures at the top of this post was due to one of the hooks detaching from its bottle.
As well launch efficiency, the reason for the launch tubes was to allow the compression line to remain dry/ This would allow the pressure to equalise between the boosters. However, looking at the failed launch with hindsight, we missed out a non-return valve. This meant that water from the main rocket filled the booster compression lines and prevented the pressure from equalising. I don’t think it was causal to the catastrophic failure, but it can’t have helped.
I went a little overboard on the parachute. In the past I’ve found charity clothing bags ideal for building parachutes, but while light, they aren’t particularly resiliant and the my choice of tether line (dental floss!) got tangled easily. So I splashed out on some Ripstop Nylon from Ebay and got sewing.
Leo Singleton‘s Bottle Rocket Handbook (PDF) had a nice section on parachute design. I chose to build an elliptical design, calculated using his Elliptical Parachute Calculator (36KB ZIP)
My first parachute took the defaults from the tool and ended up a rather too large 1M diameter, still it would be a nice gentle float down. As I didn’t think I’d be able to deploy this on its own, I built a drogue of 40cm.
Drogue (40cm) and main (1m) parachutes
Again, drawing on ideas from Air Command Rockets I built a Parachute Side Deployment Mechanism, with their elastic band release modification. I didn’t have time to acquire a Servo Timer II nor much faith in guessing the timing accurately so decided to use a 35MHz radio control receiver to control the server.
Activated parachute mechanism
Parachute mechanism atop the rocket. Upper half of the top bottle contains the drogue chute and R/C release mechanism; the lower half the main chute which failed to deploy
As the main chute was too large to fit within the elastic deployment pocket, I bargained that the drogue would lift the whole mechanism from the rocket top and deploy the main. On both parachute-recovery launches the drogue deployed perfectly, but the main chute failed. With hindsight, I should have attached the drogue directly to the main and had a hole or flap for it to deploy through.
Next time, I think I’ll build a second deployment mechansim, attach a medium sized (70cm?) parachute and trigger it shortly after apogee with an altimeter. The existing R/C drogue parachute can act as a back up.
I’ve written enough for now, feel free to ask any further questions in the comments below, or in person.